Chemical Process of an Indigo Vat
Indigo is very different than the majority of plant based dyes. Where most dyes that are derived from plant material can be extracted by steeping in hot water, the dye compounds that make blue don’t work that way. Indigoid dye plants all require a process to make the dye compound water soluble and able to bind with the fibers of whatever is being dyed. Indigoid plants contain indican, which is a colorless sugar bound to another compound called indoxyl. The first step in getting an indigo dye is breaking the bond between the sugar and the indoxyl. This happens in the extraction process in water extraction, but for aizome it happens during the composting of the sukumo at which point bacteria consume the sugars. The indoxyl is then able to be oxidized, turning it into indigo by exposure to oxygen. The oxidization also separates the indigo from any other remaining material that came from the original plant matter.1
The chemical compound of indigo is not water soluble and can’t bind with fiber in this form. Indigo can be mixed into water, but not dissolved in it. To make the indigo water soluble, the oxidization has to be reversed through a process called reduction in which the pH is increased and the oxygen is extracted from the environment that the indigo is mixed into. Reduced indigo changes again as the next step of this process, becoming water soluble leuco-indigo. The difference between these two states can be well described at the difference between a fish in the ocean and salt in the ocean. The fish is suspended in the water, but not dissolved in it, much like how indigo can be mixed into water, but it is insoluble. The salt will fully dissolve in enough water, much like leuco-indigo can because it is soluble. Leuco-indigo appears yellow to yellow toned green, and this color change is a visual indicator of successful reduction. While there are many ways to reduce indigo, is aizome the reduction happens as a result of the fermentation that happens in the vat.
Indigo is also very different from most other plant based dyes because of how it binds to the fibers of whatever it is being used to dye. It is uniquely suited to creating dark colors on plant based fibers, because the water soluble leuco-indigo isn’t forming a bond with the surface of the fiber, but actually being pulled into the cell wall of the cellulose fiber, then changing back into an insoluble form through oxidization when removed from the dye vat and exposed to the air. 2
Creating a Dye Vat for Aizome Using Mature Sukumo
In a 2019 workshop held in California, Kyoko Nishimoto and Kakuo Kaji of Tokushima based indigo studio Buaisou shared a traditional vat building process, starting from cultivating the indigo and following the process through to the dyeing stage. Artisans from Buaisou are uniquely suited to teach the entirety of the craft, as they are one of the only indigo workshops in Japan that handle cultivation, sukumo fermentation, and dyeing all within the same business. I have leaned heavily on their expertise and teachings in developing my understanding of how aizome is done using sukumo, both because they are artisans from this specific tradition, but also because while many aizome dye houses are somewhat secretive about the details of their process, Buaisou enthusiastically teaches theirs.
The vat building approach they shared started with creating a wood ash water solution by combining 15 kilos of wood ash specifically from Japanese oak wood with approximately 30 gallons of water. This was done in a large plastic trash bin at the workshop, but historically wooden barrels or large pottery were the likely options. Wood is still used in the present, and pottery dye vats from a medieval workshop have been found outside Kyoto 4. The wood ash was added first, then boiling water was added a few gallons at a time. After each addition of water, the mixture was stirred. Once all of the water had been added, the mixture was left to sit overnight. After sitting overnight, the ash sediment will have settled to the bottom. The liquid is carefully scooped into a second container, with care taken to not disturb the ash layer at the bottom. This liquid will be alkaline and will help start and keep the pH level in the vat in the right range for successful indigo reduction. The ash sediment should then be covered with boiling water and stirred to create a second batch of this solution. The result will not be as strong as the first batch, and the two batches can be blended as needed to adjust the pH for use in the vat.
Blending the wood ash solutions is done in another clean vessel. The target pH recommended in the Buaisou workshop was 11.5, though it is worth noting that artisans in medieval Japan would not have been able to test for an exact number with pH test strips or a pH meter. They would have been reliant on their experience of how a solution at the correct pH smelled, felt, and reacted with other substances. Once the correct pH is achieved, hot, but not boiling water (approximately 110°F) is added to fill the vessel. This diluted wood ash solution is now ready for use.
Once the wood ash water is ready, another vessel is cleaned by using lime derived from heating sea shells until they break down into quicklime. This vessel should be as clean as possible before the lime is added, but the lime helps further reduce the presence of any undesirable microbes that might interfere with the fermentation process. Around 5 kilos of sukumo is then added to the lime scrubbed vessel, and an additional dusting of lime is applied over the sukumo. A gallon of the diluted wood ash solution should be poured over the sukumo and stirred to thoroughly dampen it. When well incorporated, more of the wood ash water should be added until the vessel is around half way full. This combination gets stirred until well mixed. This vessel will become the dye vat.
Next, the Buaisou method calls for a small amount of wheat bran to be mixed into some of the highest pH wood ash water, and briefly cooked on low heat until the bran begins to change color. Their recommended amounts were 200 grams of wheat bran to 1 liter of wood ash solution. The cooking process happens quickly, in a matter of minutes, but should be done outdoors or in a well ventilated space. This mixture is gently sprinkled onto the surface of the vat. It should not be stirred to incorporate it, but allowed to sit at the surface. The vat can now be covered and the fermentation process begin.
While the process for fermenting a dye vat using sukumo is not as time consuming as the process for creating the sukumo itself, it is still one that happens in its own time. The prepared vat will need attentive care for several days before it is ready for dyeing. The vat needs warmer temperatures at the start of fermentation, responding best to temperatures from 85-95°F, but will prefer slightly cooler temperatures after the color begins to develop in the vat. Modern aizome artisans may use electric heating options, such as warming mats, to add a little extra heat around the vat during the early days. Prior to the availability of that technology, the approach is less certain, but may have included planning to start vats during warmer months, use of hot coals, or covering with insulation materials much like those used to cover sukumo piles during the composting process.
After fermentation has begun, the vat needs to be tested daily and stirred twice daily. The pH should be maintained as close to 11 as possible. If the pH falls below this point, a small amount of the first batch of wood ash solution or lime can be added to slowly boost it back up to where it needs to be. Elevated pH is unlikely as the bacterial culture in the sukumo create small amounts of acid in the process of fermentation, slowly neutralizing the alkalinity. A small strip of cloth should be dipped daily to test for color development. The stirring should also follow a specific pattern, using a rowing motion in a single direction at first to bring the settled sukumo up from the bottom of the vat, then a circular motion to mix. All of these steps also require the utmost attention to the cleanliness of hands, samples, and all tools. Anything dipped or dropped into the vat during daily maintenance has the potential to contaminate it, which can cause the entire vat to fail.
The vat should take around 10 days to ferment and become useable, but cooler temperatures, the specific microbial culture of the sukumo used, or any variations in vat conditions can slow the process. Vat readiness is determined by the color found on the sample cloth during the daily test of the vat. Once the vat is imparting a deep, dark blue that does not easily rinse off, it is ready to use. At this stage, the vat can be stirred once per day instead of twice. The vat should be allowed to rest for at least two hours after stirring before any dyeing is done. Each time a round of dyeing is done, it should be followed by adding a cup of wood ash water to the vat to help restore the pH. The vat should also not be used every day. After two days of dyeing, the vat should be allowed to rest for a day before use is resumed. A vat built and maintained using this technique should be viable for at least 6 months of dyeing.
Water Sourcing
Water is critical element in all parts of the sukumo and vat building process. While a vat built well from mature sukumo starts with a generous initial inoculation of indigo reducing microbes, water that has been chemically treated with the intention of using additives to kill microbial cultures can destroy the desirable bacterium as well. If not killed entirely, a weakened bacterial culture makes it easier for other microbial life to flourish instead, resulting in a vat that may not develop the appropriate conditions for indigo dyeing to happen. If chemically treated water is introduced before the sukumo is mature, during the composting process, the indigo reducing bacterium may never even become established in the sukumo. For these reasons, both sukumo fermentation and indigo fermentation vats made with sukumo traditionally use captured rain water.
1Aino Keiichi , Hirota Kikue , Okamoto Takahiro , Tu Zhihao , Matsuyama Hidetoshi , Yumoto Isao. Microbial Communities Associated With Indigo Fermentation That Thrive in Anaerobic Alkaline Environments. Frontiers in Microbiology, Volume 9, 2018: DOI 10.3389/fmicb.2018.02196
2Yi, C., Tan, X., Bie, B. et al. Practical and environment-friendly indirect electrochemical reduction of indigo and dyeing. Sci Rep 10, 4927 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-61795-5
3Aino Keiichi , Hirota Kikue , Okamoto Takahiro , Tu Zhihao , Matsuyama Hidetoshi , Yumoto Isao. Microbial Communities Associated With Indigo Fermentation That Thrive in Anaerobic Alkaline Environments. Frontiers in Microbiology, Volume 9, 2018: DOI 10.3389/fmicb.2018.02196
4Hergueta, A. Traditional folk textile dyeing in Japan: diversity, meanings, and continuity of the kōbō. International Christian University of Tokyo. Volume 22, Issue 2 (Article 6 in 2022). First published in ejcjs on 17 August 2022.

